Silicone Lash Curlers vs Rubber: Surprising Safety & Comfort Tested in 2024 In the world of eyelash tools, the age-old debate between silicone and rubber curlers has taken a new turn. As beauty routines evolve, so does the quest for the perfect curl-without sacrificing comfort or safety. A 2024 study, conducted with input from 500 beauty enthusiasts and 200 dermatologists, revealed unexpected insights into these two materials, challenging long-held assumptions about their efficacy. Take the Tweezerman Classic Eyelash Curler Model No. 1034-R, a stalwart in the stainless steel category. Its rigid, polished edges promise precision but raised concerns about potential lash damage. Meanwhile, the e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler-with its replaceable rubber pad-offers a softer, more forgiving grip, appealing to those prioritizing gentleness. The Surratt Relevee Lash Curler and Shu Uemura Iconic Eyelash Curler leaned into ergonomic design, with the latter's polished finish and precise control catering to professional standards. The Revlon Extra Curl Lash Curler, meanwhile, stood out for its finger grips and non-slip mechanism, making it a favorite among users who value ease of use. But the real surprise came from the silicone contenders. While rubber is often praised for its flexibility, silicone's smooth, non-porous surface emerged as a game-changer. Lab tests showed silicone curlers reduced the risk of abrasion by 30% compared to rubber, while user feedback highlighted their "velvety embrace" of lashes. Yet, the study also noted that silicone's durability and temperature resistance made it less likely to degrade over time, potentially offering long-term safety. So, are rubber curlers obsolete? Not quite-but the 2024 results suggest silicone is quietly stealing the spotlight. Whether you're a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, the choice between these materials might just hinge on how you want to treat your lashes.